Defense of Dr. Jill Biden’s Breakfast Taco Simile,
by J.D. Meyer
Earlier this July, Dr. Jill Biden attended the Unidos US Annual Conference, but the First Lady got criticized for stating that the Hispanic community is "as unique as the breakfast tacos here in San Antonio." The previous week, President Joe Biden awarded the Presidential Medal of Freedom to Raul Izaguirre, a past director of the program. The National Association of Hispanic Journalists (NAHJ) asserted that we are not tacos. Actually, by using the words "as" or "like," makes the statement a comparison between two things--a simile. Who remembers that old rock love song, "You are like a hurricane. There's calm in your eyes"? A metaphor is a direct comparison between things that doesn't use "as" or "like." "Her smile is sunshine" was the metaphor example used by www.dictionary.com my source for these two definitions. Being like something isn't the same as asserting something is something else, so the critique is glaringly wrong.
My initial reaction to the controversy were my memories of soft tacos at taquerias--the traditional Mexican taco. As a kid growing up in Dallas, we just had corn tacos with the hard shell. Ground beef was the filling, not the variety of stew meats. Cabbage and cilantro were unheard of as vegetable toppings. Furthermore, breakfast tacos that included eggs hadn't made it to North Texas yet. La Michoacana is the major taqueria in Texas, and I've gone to this restaurant/grocery store in Dallas, Garland, and my current home for 21 years: Tyler.
So I asked myself, did Dr. Jill grow up in a city with many Hispanics? I bet she's from "way up north." So I went to the Britannica website for her biography. Dr. Jill grew up in Willow Grove, PA from age 8 through high school in 1969. Willow Grove is a suburb of Philadelphia with a population of only about 16,000 in 1990, and it's been shrinking since then. Its White population has stayed over 80% while its Hispanic population is under 5%. She got her Bachelors degree in 1975 at the University of Delaware, which is in Wilmington--a city of just over 30,000 that is nearly 90% White and 2.5% Hispanic. After earning two Masters degrees in Pennsylvania, she returned to the University of Delaware in 2007. She has taught high school--public and private--as well as community college. Dr. Biden's dissertation was on retention in the community college.
To conclude, Dr. Jill Biden is a life-long teacher who merely used a simile to express her joy over discovering the diversity of soft breakfast tacos in San Antonio. Assuming she's a racist is ridiculous. She's the first First Lady to keep her job while serving as the First Lady. My suggestion for her is to hook up with "AOC" Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, a Democrat congresswoman from New York who used to work at a taqueria. Keep searching the taquerias menus!